Speculation about authorship became rampant when residents of Circleville, Ohio, began receiving anonymous threatening letters in the late 1970s. In the end, Paul Freshour’s estranged wife claimed he was the one who wrote the letter. Paul, who has always claimed nothing to do with them, was judged differently in court. So if you’re wondering what happened to him since then, you’ve come to the right place.
However, Paul had been hoping that authorities would look into Ron’s death more closely. The writer threatens Ron’s life, and he dies suddenly. Paul hopes the police will find the author’s identity. Then, in February 1983, Mary stopped in the street to pull out an obscene sign, only to find it had been tampered with twine and cardboard. Inside the box is a pistol designed to fire. The incomplete serial number on the gun helped authorities trace the gun to a colleague of Paul’s who said he sold the gun to Paul.
When police spoke to Karen, she had just divorced Paul. She claimed that Paul was angry with Mary and that he wrote Circleville’s letter. Mary, who denies having an affair with Gordon, started dating Gordon after Ron’s death. Karen said she once found some letters in the house but she never kept them or showed them to police at the time. While Paul admitted the gun was his, he claimed it was stolen. Some witnesses testified that Paul was at home the day Mary discovered the trap.
Furthermore, there is no physical evidence linking Paul to the box. During Paul’s trial in 1983, a judge allowed the letters to be produced as evidence, and prosecutors claimed Paul was the one who wrote them. Manuscript experts testified that Paul may have been the author of the letters. However, the evidence presented was sufficient for the jury to convict Paul of attempted murder.
How did Paul Freshour die?
Based on this conviction, Paul was sentenced to 7 to 25 years in prison. However, he has always maintained that he did not write the letters. In prison, he was isolated and deprived of pen and paper. However, the letters continued. One of them talked about setting up Paul, leading to speculation that Karen might be involved. A witness reported a man in the area matching Karen’s friend’s description just 20 minutes after Mary found the box. The car he was in was very similar to Karen’s brother’s car.
Who is Paul Freshour?
Paul Freshour came to the attention of the authorities sometime in 1977 when the letters were delivered to various recipients. The first went to Mary Gillispie, a school bus driver married to Ron Gillispie. The letter accused her of having an affair with the principal and urged her to stop. The writer even threatened Mary’s daughter. At the time, Paul was married to Ron’s sister Karen Sue.
Image credit: Unsolved Mysteries – The Complete Collection/YouTube
In August 1977, Ron died in a car accident. He got a call that angered him and later told his daughter he would confront the person who wrote the letter. However, Ron crashed his car into a tree, killing him. Authorities also found a gun that had fired under his body. While some believe Ron may have shot the letter writer, the police did not.